Hand steadiness decides a lot here: Smudged Black Eyeliner and Eyeshadow Over Pencil Liner forgive shaky lines, while Liquid Liner and the Gel Eyeliner Winged Look reward a calm, practiced hand.
These 8 run from Smudged Black Eyeliner, where the mess is the look, to Liquid Liner, which needs a slow, careful pull. Brown shadow, gel liner and pencil sit in between, and each one forgives a different kind of mistake.
1. Eyeshadow Over Pencil Liner
Layering shadow over pencil liner is the move that keeps a smoky eye from looking like a stripe.
Pencil stays creamy for only a few seconds, so press a dark shadow onto it with a small brush right away and the edge softens into a blended finish.
A black or deep brown shadow matched to the liner gives the most depth. I prefer tapping the shadow on rather than sweeping, so the line stays where you put it.
To create a lush, textured smoky eye (mine always look too flat and heavy), Kendall suggests starting with a cream liner to create a base and then going in with eyeshadow.
— Glamour
2. Brown Eyeshadow Smoky Eye
Brown is the forgiving route to a smoky eye, and bronze or gold shimmer shows why: the shade reads as warm definition instead of a hard black frame.
Beginners get a smudge that looks intentional even when the blending is imperfect.
Pair brown shadow with a dark pencil along the lashes, then blend the edge upward. I would pick this over black for daytime, though it gives up some of the drama.
3. Pencil Liner Base
A pencil liner base does the shaping before any color goes on. Line the upper lash line and the lower one with pencil, and you have a guide for where the smoke should sit.
Use a pencil with some slip, since a dry one tugs at the skin. Keep the line a little rough on purpose: a rough line smudges and blends much more easily than a neat one.
4. Liquid Liner
Liquid liner is how I add a crisp finish on top of a smoky eye. A sharp black wing stands out against dark shadow because its edge stays clean while everything around it is blended.
Shadow goes on first, and the liquid flick comes last, so powder fallout never smudges that crisp line.
Start from the outer corner and pull the line toward the end of the brow, then fill in along the lashes. Liquid is less forgiving than pencil, so beginners should go slowly.
5. Finish with Mascara
Mascara is the last step, and a smoky eye looks unfinished without it. Dark, long lashes balance heavy liner so the eye still looks open.
Wiggle the wand at the base and pull it through to the tips.
Add a second coat once the first is tacky, not wet, to avoid clumps. Do it after the shadow, since fallout is easier to wipe away before mascara goes on.
6. Shimmery Bronze
Shimmery bronze gives a smoky eye warmth and light where black gives only depth. The metallic finish catches light on the lid, which suits a quick look that still seems polished.
Press the shimmer on with a fingertip or a flat brush, since patting packs on more pigment than sweeping.
Keep the shadow on the lid and blend only the edges. Pair it with dark mascara, as above, so the lashes do not fade next to the glow.
7. Gel Eyeliner Winged Look
Gel liner is what I reach for when I want a thick wing that holds up against dark smoky shadow. It has more body than pencil, so the line goes down wide and opaque in one pass.
Draw the wing outward from the outer corner first, then fill in along the lashes so the thickness looks even. Do this after the shadow, as with liquid, so fallout never dirties the edge.
Gel gives you a little time to fix a mistake, which makes it friendlier than liquid for beginners.
8. Smudged Black Eyeliner
Heavily smudged black liner on both the upper and lower lash lines is the easiest smoky eye to get right, because the mess is the look. Nobody needs a clean edge here.
Draw a rough line along each lash line, then smudge it outward with a small brush or a fingertip while the pencil is still soft. Work quickly, since a pencil that has set will not blend.
Black gives the most drama, though it looks harsh in daylight. For a softer day version, I would smudge less and keep the lower line thin.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best eyeliner for smoky eyes?
It depends on the look. For a crisp wing on top of dark shadow, I pick gel liner, since it goes down thick and opaque in one pass and gives you a little time to fix mistakes.
Liquid gives the sharpest edge but is less forgiving. For a soft, blended smoke, a pencil with some slip works best because it stays workable long enough to smudge.
What color of eyeliner makes you look younger?
I can’t point to a color that takes years off, but brown is the softer choice for daytime.
For a softer, more youthful frame, I reach for brown liner with a bronze or gold glint, since it defines the eye without the stark outline black leaves.
How can I create quick and easy smoky eyes?
Draw a slightly rough pencil line along the upper and lower lash lines, then press a dark shadow onto it right away with a small brush while the pencil is still creamy.
Blend only the edges, then finish with mascara. If speed is the goal, a black pencil rubbed out with a fingertip along both lash lines wins, because a little mess is exactly what makes the look work.
